Murder convictions highlight Roma discrimination in Europe
A court in Hungary has jailed three men for life and a fourth for 13 years for a series of killings targeting the Roma population. Advocacy groups say violence, intimidation and discrimination are experienced daily by the Roma — and not just in their historic homelands in Eastern Europe.
The four convicted men were part of a gang that carried out attacks over 13 months in 2008 and 2009, killing six people and leaving Hungary’s Roma population terrified.
In one attack in the village of Tatarszentgyorgy, the gang set fire to a house before opening fire on the occupants. Robert Csorba and his 4-year-old son were killed and a girl seriously wounded.
Robert’s mother Erzsebet Csorba welcomed the court verdict — but said she had no faith that the case would deliver wider justice for the Roma.
“I can’t say it’s easier now, it’s more difficult. It might be harder for us, because of all the heartache that made us numb to life,” said Csorba.
For Amnesty International’s Barbora Cernusakova, Hungary’s criminal justice system is failing the Roma.
“The police don’t really have guidelines on how to deal with hate crimes, and lack general guidelines on how to deal with this specific type of crimes,” said Cernusakova. “And also it lacks expertise.”
In 2009, human rights groups tried to use the Csorbas funerals to encourage understanding between Roma and other Hungarians.
But four years on little has changed, says Szilvia Varro from the advocacy group Communication Center X.
“Hungarian society is very fragmented and broken into two parts,” said Varro. “There are our dead and their dead, there is our memory and your memory, and it’s very rare to bridge that division.”
Roma have lived in Hungary and its neighboring countries for centuries. Support groups say the fall of communism — and more recently the global financial crisis — hit the Roma disproportionately hard.
Meanwhile, Amnesty’s Cernusakova says anti-Roma political parties like Jobbik are on the rise.
“There were many allegations in the past that Jobbik was actually using Roma and other groups as scapegoats for the general feeling of discomfort due to the economic crisis,” she said.
Cernusakova says Roma also suffer discrimination in access to education and healthcare.
“Discrimination cuts throughout their lives and affects them from early childhood pretty much until the end of their lives,” she said. “It’s one of the biggest communities in Europe that is discriminated [against] in this way. It’s also not only a problem of Eastern Europe, especially after the expulsions from France and the eviction of camps in Italy.”
Starting in January 2014, Romanian and Bulgarian citizens — including ethnic Roma — will be permitted free movement within Europe’s labor market. The European Union has called on member states to do more to integrate Europe’s 12-million-strong Roma population.
But advocacy groups say it’s time the EU took punitive measures against countries they accuse of continued discrimination.
(Photo: Amir Darafsheh)